RELIGION, NATION, MARRIAGE: THE LOYALTIES OF MEN
PRAY, WORK, STUDY, PROTECT: THE DUTIES OF MEN


Monday, February 12, 2018

Pope Francis Is Not "Abandoning Chinese Christians"


by David Pence

In the last week several faithful Catholic women have come to me and said their hearts were breaking after hearing reports from the global Catholic TV network(EWTN) that Pope Francis was "abandoning Christians in China". One broke down in tears. She is prone to neither hysteria nor hyperbole.

Here is the Pope discussing China in his most extensive interview on China.  Here is the best explanation of the Pope's approach in an article by Francesco Sisci the Italian Sinologist who did the interview for Asia Times. A more thorough commentary is found in the works of  the Pope's nephew and fellow Jesuit,  Jose Luis Narvaja (a good English translation of his work is needed. It would also be helpful to see a profile of Fr. Jose to show that ancient practice of Papal nepotism can be a service to the Church. That sacralization of male kinship relations is not always an occasion for wealth transfer and graft. ) These excellent online commentaries don't make it in the conservative "Catholic news around the web" compilations. The righteous Western commentators have missed the much larger civilizational story about China and the Church that a multilingual writer like Sisci living in China seems to appreciate.  

There is a blind spot among American free market capitalists against Pope Francis. They dominate the Catholic "conservative media". Their destructive anti-filial approach has given room to  the Catholic sexual left who take a different approach to the pontiff. The left selectively quotes Francis and then claim him as their own. (I believe this strategy will soon be abandoned as the Pope becomes clearer on the unacceptable nature of granting any social credence to homosexual relations.)

The Pope actually has a very sophisticated approach to diplomacy. He respects the existence of nations as a development of the polis and thus a social good in itself. He respects nations as corporate realities more than the ideas of leftist or conservative ideologies. Capitalism vs Communism is yesterday's knot. He sees China as a living civilization more than an ideology.  Like the rulers of China, he has seen the human catastrophe that follows the breakdown of constituted social order. When he visits heads of states, he does not preach about human rights. He does not play  "the nag" to posture as the prophet. His representatives emphasize to the Chinese that Pope Francis is Pope not of the West but the South. The new Pope represents Global Christianity not Western Civilization and he fully understands the crucial role of China in establishing a sensibility of harmony amidst the nations.

                                                                     
                                                          Statue of Matteo Ricci, in Macau, China

The unification of Korea, reconciliation with Russia, and avoiding the Thucydides trap of war with a rising China are all possible and desirable goals of Christian realists. The Pope is not an infallible guide for American national foreign policy in achieving these ends. He does not carry the responsibilities of the national sword. His Vatican policy however is much more profound than the protests of his American Catholic Republican critics.  He treats China as a legitimate social organism and a great civilization with its own spiritual heritage of harmony and order. He seeks Christian unity with Russia. He addresses nations as corporate wholes even if the Catholics are a small part of the population. This is a highly significant approach in asserting the fraternity which binds Catholics with other members of a common territory as fellow citizens. This is soothing music to civilizations that prize social order and the loyalty of all citizens.

When the Pope was a bishop in Argentina his fiercest critics were leftist intellectuals. Today his detractors in America are "conservative intellectuals". Their well-publicized filial disrespect has confused many faithful Catholics labeling Pope Francis as a "typical modern Jesuit." Nothing could be further from the truth. The Pope spends a good deal of his day in a regular habit of prayer. Always start there!! He believes in a personal Devil not a "symbol of evil." That puts him at odds with the superior general of the Jesuits. His approach to gender differences is that male and female beings  are a given in the created order which must be respected as part of ecological morality. His brilliant encyclical on ecology and the created order was dismissed and under-reported by the Catholic right because he nodded to the possibility of global warning.

Pope Francis  considers even the suggestion of female priests as a betrayal of both femininity and the priesthood. That doesn't exactly make him a James Martin Jesuit or even a Cardinal O'Malley type bishop.(O'Malley on NBC TV: "If I were founding church, I'd love to have women priests. But Christ founded it and what He has given us is something different.") The Pope is much clearer on the natural goodness of the sexual binary than almost all of his American or European fellow bishops.
The Pope believes that politics is the noble science of constituting and maintaining the social order of the polis -the unity of social organization. His understanding is much different than right and left bishops lobbying on "their issues." The Pope calls the gender ideology of the rich countries an attempt at "ideological colonization." We doubt Mr. Arroyo and his papal lynch mob at EWTN will begin any stories on the Holy Father with that headline.

The nations and major religions are experiencing a post Cold War paradigm shift. The Pope is playing his part -- and playing it quite well. The Christian nations have our part to play as well. It is very different than the Pope's and involves the defense of borders and at times the threat and use of military force. The Christian nations must guard from the global capitalism of the right and the sexual anarchy of the left. We must also reject the atheistic tradition of Social Darwinism organizing regional military  coalitions of smaller nations against the largest nation in each region. That strategy of perpetual war is not the Providential destiny of the nations and should not be the policy of a Christian nation. We will not understand our role as a Christian nation until we see how the movement of Global Christianity has outgrown the categories of the West and the Cold War. Christians and nationalists from Eastern Europe, France, Russia, South Korea, and America can offer  humanity a new sense of direction, purpose and order after the bloody twentieth century. Such a perspective of global Christianity and strong national identities can emerge.
The great gift of Mother Angelica's TV outreach is being squandered by her male heirs. Let us pray that this Lent there might be a renewed sense of  piety from the arrogant commentators from the North toward the Pope from the Global South. Filial piety will provide a much clearer vision of the truth than prejudging our father's every move through the clouded lens of the defunct alliances of the Cold War. And it will leave the hearts of some very fine Catholic women a good deal less troubled.
                                                       


AOA  on an ecclesial approach  to our elder brother in China.  Christianity and China  have an ancient and bloody history that must be understood in terms of the unfolding drama and spiritual destiny of the human species and its largest nation.
AOA  on American foreign policy getting beyond the Cold War and respecting China as our WWII ally and a great civilization. Christian Realism and a new paradigm for China.

Paul Kengor for the opposition. Professor Kengor thinks the Pope Francis China policy a capitulation. He is an honest historian and has never been reflexively anti Francis. His argument should be heard.

A very good background on the Patriotic and "underground" Church in China  by Phil Lawler at Catholic Culture.
AOA on Understanding Pope Francis by listening to him.

Finally Robert Moynihan on the Pope and His China Dream  ...an insightful Vatican correspondent recounts an experience in Rome:
"A few months ago, I was standing by La Vittoria restaurant on the via delle Fornaci in Rome following a dinner with friends. It was a quiet, warm summer evening, about 10 p.m., already dark. An Italian man whom I knew came walking briskly down the street. He is an internationally respected writer on geopolitical affairs. I stopped him, greeted him, and asked him what he was working on at the moment. "China!" he said. His hair was disheveled and standing almost on end in different places.

"China?" I said. "Yes! The Pope and his advisors would like to make a breakthrough in China! It's their #1 priority. Nothing else is even remotely as important to them." "Ah!" I replied, mentally rifling though a series of other matters of concern in mid-2017: the Church's liturgy, the dubia... the bloody conflicts in Libya and Syria and the consequent massive immigration into Europe... the Vatican's opaque finances... the tragic conflict in Ukraine... the post-Christian West's seemingly Gnostic longing for, and embrace of, what will transcend man and perhaps dominate man, the "transhuman," the "superhuman"... "Ok," I said. "Interesting. So, what is the vision?"

"Simple!" my friend replied. "The people of China, so hard-working, so oriented toward becoming successful, in their hundreds of millions, are nevertheless, of course, souls, souls with a hunger for the divine, for the eternal, for God..." He stopped and pointed toward the Apostolic Palace in the distance, above the colonnade. "And that is something about which the Church..." (he shook his finger at the Vatican palaces) "knows very much, for two millennia now. And the Chinese government, despite its best efforts, does not, and cannot, fully understand this hunger. "And so we have these two great powers, one secular, one spiritual. And the Pope is persuaded that if the Chinese government gives the Church an opening to function in China, something extraordinary will happen." "Like what?" I asked.

"Mass conversions," the excited writer said to me. "By the millions. When the Church presents Jesus Christ to the Chinese people, when the sacraments are celebrated in churches in every part of the country, the people will respond because they are spiritually thirsty, spiritually starving. What the Church offers has been systematically excluded from every aspect of Chinese life, which was traditionally rooted in a reverent Confucianism, which respected elders and nature's laws. All that was uprooted in the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s. But the desire for something more remains, for it is a human desire, intrinsic to our nature. And for this reason, the Pope thinks the Chinese people will be fascinated by the Church and the Christian message, and ultimately, by Jesus Christ. And he believes there may well be, if there is an opening, perhaps 100 million Catholics in China in 10 years, perhaps 200 million in 20 years. Making China the largest Catholic country by number of believers in the world. And that would have extraordinary consequences."

"But the Chinese government..." I said. "Would the government ever allow such a thing?" "Good question," he said. "No one knows the answer. But the bet is that the situation will become uncontrollable. The longing for the faith, for the transcendent, will become a cultural phenomenon, an explosion of spiritual force. And the government will be unable to take repressive measures because the longing will be too widespread, and open repression too negative for the country's global image. So the conversions will come, and they will be massive." And he summed up: "But one thing is quite clear: this Pope is the first 'post-Western' Pope. He sees far beyond the old boundaries of what we called Christendom." We talked a while longer, and then parted. But I did not forget the conversation.

ADDENDUM SEPT 22, 2018  A Vatican-China Accord has been struck.

Saturday, February 10, 2018

Religion and Geopolitics Review: Saturday, February 10

by Dr. David Pence and A. Joseph Lynch


WEEKLY BRIEF

Neoconservatives and "Never Trump" Republicans Played Roles in  "Collusion Dossier."  

The opposition to Donald Trump was never just Democrats. The "never Trumpers" from Weekly Standard's William Kristol to Arizona's John McCain hate him. The foreign policy establishment feared him deeply. The mainstream press began with ridicule then settled into opposition. They didn't need the DNC or Hillary Clinton to tell them Mr Trump was a threat to their worldview. They didn't need a command center for their efforts any more than Lee Harvey Oswald needed the American Communist Party or the Kremlin to assassinate President Kennedy. People bound by hatred cannot build a community but they can effectively attack a common opponent. Here are some previous  AOA entries with good links outlining the main actors:
FROM AOA ON MARCH 5, 2016 - THE NEO-CONS WILL SUPPORT HILLARY: Robert Kagan, a neocon intellectual, now says in the open what a lot of Pat Buchanan conservatives have said will happen all along. The neoconservatives of the Weekly Standard who now have their champion in Marco Rubio, must soon admit that their next closest foreign policy ally is Hillary Clinton. This group of "conservatives" have never cared about the sexual inversion of the gender ideology. They are petrified of Donald Trump. Mr. Kagan, who now has endorsed the lady who gave us Libya, is married to the lady who gave us the Ukraine mess: Victoria Nuland. Even though Vicki was a Bush appointee, Hillary Clinton in proper feminist fashion was instrumental in aiding Nuland's career rise in the State Department. Mrs. Nuland played the pivotal role as our assistant Secretary of State for European Affairs in the collapse of diplomacy in the Ukraine. Kagan, with more than fifty other GOP neocons, signed an open letter against Donald Trump this week on War on the Rocks. More on Robert Kagan as he stumped for Hillary.

FROM AOA ON NOV 4, 2017 - THE RUSSIAN STORY IS NOT A DEMOCRATIC PARTY STORY THOUGH THEY WENT ALONG. IT IS JOURNALISTS SOME NEOCON SOME CNN SOME WALL STREET JOURNAL:

NEOCONS AND DNC AFTER THE PRESIDENT: The dossier on Trump and origins of the Trump Russia collusion story. They all want to get him. William Kristol of the Weekly Standard founded the journal of his son-in-law Matthew Continetti of the Washington Free Beacon. They are the originators of the dossier against Donald Trump later picked up by the much larger cash cows of the Democratic Party and Hillary Clinton's opposition research team. The "Never Trump" neocons felt Trump was not interventionist enough in foreign policy and opposed him from the beginning 'from the right.". They are at the center of the secular Jewish wing of neoconservatives who came from the incestuous world of East Coast Jewish atheist intellectuals involved with leftist organizations until their "move to the right." Weekly Standard writers are regulars on Fox News opinion shows and have not emphasized this aspect of the dossier. Fusion GPS - the dossier and links to mainstream media.

THE NEFARIOUS ROLE OF JOHN MCCAIN AND HIS AIDE, DAVID KRAMER, WHO DIRECTED A MCCAIN FOUNDATION AMPLY FUNDED BY SAUDIS AND MILITARY SUPPLIERS: McCain and his Aide 12/27/2017.   More on Aide 12/2017.

GPS FOUNDER SIMPSON SAID HE HAD PERFECT PERSON TO GET DOSSIER TO FBI AND IT WOULDN'T BE A DEMOCRAT: A man who hated Trump more than Hillary was John McCain.

I. POPE FRANCIS AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH

THE POPEWhat happened to bold reform? A chance to draw the line as the decadent rich German bishops propose to bless an abomination. We have argued that Pope Francis is not a "modern Jesuit" or a decadent Westerner. On the sexual order and the Sacred Order, he is Catholic. He has always argued that the way to fight the "angels of light" (demons who pose as purveyors of the good) is to give them plenty of room and they will eventually declare themselves. The German bishops are now showing us the twisted face of Satan in the priestly kiss of Judas.

THE MEANEST FANS AND THE MOST CHRISTIAN QUARTERBACKS: The city of brotherly love has two Christian stars who act like brothers. Philadelphia Eagles locker room after Super Bowl victory ended in the team kneeling to pray the Our Father. It's been good year for Christian quarterbacks after Tua Tagovailoa and Coach Saban's Alabama won the College championship. Saban's faith helped recruit the best quarterback in college football.

CARDINAL ERDO FROM HUNGARY COMES TO COLUMBIA, NEW YORK: A report on his talk on On Religion and Secular States. The majority of voters and certainly a judge applying a modern concept of evolving justice against prescriptive law can subvert fundamental truths necessary to govern for the Common Good. On the same subject Fr. Thomas White on the Metaphysics of Democracy.


II. ISLAM AND THE MIDDLE EAST

IN YEMEN HOUTHIS, SAUDIS, UAE SEPARATISTSThere is no Sunni coalition.

ISRAEL AND EGYPTAlliance in the Sinai.


III. CULTURE OF LIFE, CULTURE OF PROTECTION

HIGH FIVE TO PROTECT LATE TERM ABORTION: What disgusts one? What is repulsive? What is an abomination? Who celebrates the feminist Aztecs and child sacrifice to careerism?

THE BEAUTY OF ORDER: A review of James Wilson book on the soul, truth, goodness and beauty.

SECULAR HUMANISMNo piety nor God by Joseph Sobran.

ON BEING A MAN BY FR. LARRY RICHARDS"To act like a man means to act like Jesus because Jesus was the perfect man. So what does that mean? It means that we lay down our life for others. In the world, to be a man, you go into the Navy, the Air Force or the Marines. And many of them die, for their country and for others. That’s what a man does. And yet, too often, men who are Christian men don’t want to die. They come to Jesus for what Jesus can do for them. “He’ll bless me, He’ll protect me, He’ll take care of my family.” No, you come to Jesus to learn how to be crucified with Christ. So that you can now give your life for God and give your life for others. When you do that, of course, you’re going to find true life, eternal life, and you’re going to be life-giving.

"But isn’t it amazing, even when you go to the Eucharist, that for anything else to live, something else has to die? For you to eat dinner tonight, whether you have steak or chicken or something, something gave up its life so that you could live today. … Something dies to give life to others; it’s just the way life works. So when men learn that it isn’t about taking care of me, but about living my life for others—that is the deepest need in the Church today."

MEMORY, MEN, AND SEXUAL IDENTITYA terrific talk to a Catholic men's conference in Arizona ("Into the Breach" Conference) by Archbishop Chaput.

THE INVERSION RITUAL: Is there a public sisterhood of work and duty equivalent to the masculine public identities of national citizenship and religious brotherhood? Here is Elizabeth Warren the great white hope of middle class feminism calling women together not to provide protection (the classic task of politics) but in adolescent protest wearing "Pussy hats." Who is vulgar? Who is out of touch with reality? Mature women bond in small groups as mothers sharing the very localized particular tasks of family protection. Neighborhoods are real female social networks. Mary visiting Elizabeth is true female bonding. Cities, Nations, and Religions are something quite beyond Sister Liz and the feminist fantasy. There are no Apostles, Founding Fathers, or Knights of the Roundtable in Female Bonding History. Let us reflect. In the brave new world of the sexual revolution, men couple in sexual intimacy and females form large "political" groups. Both notions are ahistorical and unnatural. But religious people who clearly see that homosexual bonds are unnatural are speechless in exposing the feminist fantasy of a public sisterhood for the common good. The feminist public is a coalition of individuals for the advancement of private careers and the protection of abortion as a medical right. It is as unnatural and sinister as gay marriage. Feminists have elevated an adult male using abusive language or striking an adult  female as a greater act of domestic violence than an adult woman killing her own child. Bringing a sense of moral proportion to the outrage racket is a subject for  Bishops and culture writers. Let's see some plain talk about the many facets of the sexual inversion ritual. A good forum for such analysis would be religious leaders speaking and preaching to large groups of Christian men.

JORDAN PETERSON ON LIFE, PURPOSE, ATTENTIVENESSAOA on Jordan Peterson

On Mass Killers: "Better to kill the innocent than guilty if you are trying to object to the structure of reality"

On Good and Evil: "To be touched by malevolence shatters one and we need a deeper sense of the world." "You need an imagination for evil." "If you can’t think like an evil one - you can't beat that evil one" "A harmless man is not a good man. The best man is a dangerous man who has his danger under control"

On Purpose, Motivation, and Addiction: "The purposeless rat is susceptible to addiction" "An incentive reward system is much more powerful at focusing attention quelling anxiety" "Religion lays out worthwhile goals to build on. Set goals for life vs set goals for just job." "Larger goals allow lesser activities to take on more meaning" "Sit down and do a map of good future and bad future - judge the day's schedule in those terms."

On Leadership and Hierarchy: Leaders sustain position in hierarchy by grooming friendships.

On Attentiveness:  "Specify your aim... lots of white in our eyes so we can look and know what we are looking at." “Set your face” this helps in mate selection.

Friday, February 9, 2018

You are a Priest Forever: Four Books with Frederick Blonigen


'Parish Priest' by Jack Butler Yeats
(brother of the famous poet)


The Catholic priesthood has been under demonic attack ever since Christ instituted the sacrament of Holy Orders and ordained His Apostles as the first priests. Satan fears the priesthood because he knows Christ endowed spiritual authority in the men He called: authority to administer the sacraments, authority to make Christ fully present in the Mass, authority to forgive sins, authority to preach and teach the Word of God. Priests are given a specific mandate to drive out demons. The Evil One understands the Apostolic communal body as the living foundation stones of the New Temple. The Great Deceiver will do anything to undermine and destroy Christ’s holy priesthood. In our own time, Satan’s attack against the priesthood has intensified, most obviously in the reappearance of the Judas priest as a sexual predator. This scandal of desacralization has been fed by allowing homosexual men to be ordained priests. Nothing so disrupts the ordered public love of brothers under the Father as the perversion of that love by incest masquerading as intimacy. The holiest of the sacral brotherhoods has been once again betrayed by a kiss. Over 80 percent of the sexual abuses cases involved homosexual priests abusing teenage boys.

The damage done to the priesthood is incalculable. Despite the enormous suffering endured by abuse victims, the billions of dollars of parish contributions paid in law suits to lawyers and victims, and the tremendous loss of confidence in clerical authority that has ensued, the homosexual network within the priesthood and episcopacy continues to do the devil’s work of corruption. A great cleansing is still needed to eradicate this diabolical network. Through the grace and guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the courage of bishops within the Church, the disorder can be removed. The Catholic priesthood can again be the sacral brotherhood Christ instituted on the night before He died.

Today’s fractured fraternity makes it more important than ever to remember the indispensable role of the Catholic priesthood and the countless holy, brave, and dedicated priests who served God’s people in a spirit of selfless love. Four recent books renew our love and reverence for the priesthood established by the Eternal Priest, Jesus Christ.

Since its inception, Ignatius Press has published the translated works of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. A recent publication, Teaching and Learning the Love of God: Being a Priest Today, is a beautiful and inspiring collection of homilies delivered by Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict XVI) over a period of sixty years on the nature and purpose of the priesthood. Reading these insightful homilies, one immediately senses a man of deep prayer. Pope Francis begins his forward: "Every time I read the works of Joseph Ratzinger/ Benedict XVI, it becomes clear to me that he pursued theology ‘on his knees’ and still does: on his knees, because we see that he is not only a preeminent theologian and master of the faith, but a man who really believes, really prays."  Distinguished Catholic historian Dr. James Hitchcock argues that Pope Benedict XVI was the single greatest theologian ever to sit on the Chair of St. Peter, and that includes such magisterial popes and Doctors of the Church as St. Leo the Great and St. Gregory the Great and the recent papacy of St. Pope John Paul II.  At the Chrism Mass on April 11, 1979, in Munich, in a homily entitled “Becoming ‘Spiritual Clergymen’ in the Breathing Space of the Spirit,” the future pope says, “The priest must first and foremost be a man who believes. This is the center of all his activity, and if it is not present, then nothing really happens anymore.... People expect above all a priest with deep faith, a priest who prays, a priest who lives according to the program of the Beatitudes.”

                                              Benedict with Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew                                           
(Istanbul 2006)

At another Chrism Mass in Munich (April 15, 1981), in a homily entitled: ”Eucharist and Pentecost as the Origin of the Church,” Joseph Ratzinger preaches on the priest with the Holy Spirit: “And finally: the Holy Spirit is mission. At the end of the Mass come the words, ‘Ite missa est’. ‘Go it is mission! And it is not wrong that this key word in tradition gave the name ‘Mass’ to the whole event, because this whole thing is mission, because all of God’s deeds always exist for others. The Holy Spirit always works under the banner of "For"; he never merely comes to someone privately; rather, he always comes so that something can be handed on. He is always the mission, the appeal to hand on. And so we should take into ourselves anew this law of "For". It is depicted in Sacred Scripture when the Holy Spirit appears in the image of the fiery tongue. Fire is the power that warms and brightens. ‘Did not our hearts burn within us...while he opened to us the Scripture?’ ( Lk.24:32) Only someone who himself is burning can kindle. We must become burning Christians. We must make that journey of the disciples of Emmaus with him, in which we let him make us burn with his word, in which we submit to and expose ourselves to the fire that makes separated elements molten and combines them and creates unity.”

A third homily from a sixtieth priestly jubilee Mass for a priest-friend in Munich in 1983 is entitled “The Great Venture of Priestly Service. ” This service though is not waiting on tables but offering the sacrifice of praise and prayer.  Pope Benedict says, "Only someone who enters into Christ’s solitude with the Father can get to know him. Someone who does not go in will, like the people then, take him for a prophet, a social revolutionary, or for whatever else fits his world view. Only by entering into his inmost being by praying with him does it dawn on us who He is: the Son of the living God. Therefore part of being a priest is being one who personally prays, who in the beautiful prayers of our tradition— the Way of the Cross and the Rosary—as it were, lets his heart be filled with God and in the Divine Office prays along with the prayer of the millennia and thereby, so to speak, becomes Catholic and broadens himself into the prayer of all ages. Only in this way can he prepare to be the voice of Jesus Christ in the Mass, to speak with the I of Jesus Christ, to say, ‘This is my Body.’ No one can do this on his own, and thank God the validity of our sacraments depends, not on our sanctity, but solely on the Lord’s mercies, which are always present. And yet how could we represent him, dare to give him a voice, if we have not become close to him."

This collection of homilies by Pope Benedict XVI on the priesthood is almost 400 pages long. The relatively short addresses are best read one or two gems at a time. It is a perfect gift for your parish priest, for a priest friend, for a seminarian or for anyone who wants to read profound and timeless reflections on the vocation of the Catholic priesthood.

A second recent book, The Joy of Being a Priest: Following the Cure of Ars, is written by  Christoph Cardinal Schonborn, Archbishop of Vienna. It is based on six talks given by Cardinal Schonborn to an international group of priests in the French village of Ars made famous by its holy pastor John Vianney (1786-1859). Topics include: Understanding  the priesthood in light of Vatican II; Prayer and spiritual combat; The Eucharist and pastoral charity; Being an instrument of God’s mercy in the confessional; Preaching the Word of God effectively; and The role of Mary in the life of the priest. Sprinkled throughout these splendid talks are memorable stories, anecdotes, and famous words from the Cure of Ars himself. For example, St. John Vianney’s definition of the priesthood: “The priesthood is the love of the heart of Jesus... Were we to fully realize what a priest is on earth, we would die , not of fright but of love.” To a priest friend, St. John Vianney explained how he often did penance for those who came to him for confession: “I will tell you my recipe: I give sinners a small penance and the rest I do in their place.” There is also the wonderful story of St. John Vianney’s arrival at Ars. Unable to find his way to Ars the first time because of the fog, he asked a young boy taking care of sheep the way to Ars. The young boy showed him the road to the village and in turn St. John Vianney said to him: “My young friend, you have shown me the way to Ars; I shall show you the way to heaven.”

The parish church of Ars

Schonborn’s insights on the sacraments of Penance and the Eucharist are especially memorable. Cardinal Schonborn is struck that on the evening of Easter when Christ appears in the upper room to the fearful Apostles, He greets them with a message of peace. He does not reproach them for their sins over the weekend but gives them the power to forgive sins. To quote Cardinal Schonborn: "Is this not the central point in rediscovering the sacrament of Reconciliation: his pardon, his mercy! Actually, Jesus has pardoned us in advance! His mercy precedes all our sins. This really turns all our ideas upside down. We suppose that God pardons us if we change our lives. The contrary is true: it is because we encounter the stunning pardon of Jesus that we convert and change  our lives. How difficult it is for us, sometimes, to enter into this logic! ‘He first loved us’(1 Jn. 4:19)."

In his talk on the Eucharist, Cardinal Schonborn reminds his retreatants that at the very heart of their priestly life is the Holy Mass. It is, he says, “the measure, the nucleus, the source of our ministry as priests.” The Cardinal comments on the great joy St. John Vianney always demonstrated when he prayed the Mass. It was a special moment to see the Cure of Ars look with such tender love at the host after he had consecrated it. Routinely, Fr. Vianney’s sermon at Mass was simply to point to the tabernacle and say to the people, “Jesus is really there and if only you knew how much he loves you.” The cardinal’s message is that all priests imitate their patron saint, John Vianney, and demonstrate the joy of following Jesus by Eucharist-centered lives. That simple priest was the Church's response to the bloody guillotines of the Enlightenment's French Revolution.  He renewed the great Catholic cultural institution by which we think globally and act locally. For it is only a holy priest who can collect scattered sinners into a coherent household of love centered on Penance and the Eucharist. Only the priest can give us the Catholic parish.      

The Priest Barracks: Dachau, 1938-1945 by French journalist Guillaume Zeller. Dachau, in the heart of Bavaria, was known as the "priests’ concentration camp." This Nazi camp had thirty barracks and three of them were occupied by clergy from 1938 to 1945. The vast majority of the Catholic men in the three barracks were the 2,579 priests, monks, and seminarians from all over Europe but especially from Poland and Germany. More than a third of the those inmates in the “priest block” (1,034) died at the hands of their Nazi captors. This book is an extraordinary account of brutality encountering holiness. The intense hatred of the Nazi regime for Christianity was manifested with special ferocity in the priest barracks at Dachau. Precisely because they were priests, many of the prisoners were treated with additional cruelty by both the guards and fellow prisoners. Suffering was intense: long hours of grinding work, a starvation diet, rampant disease, and prisoners being used in ghoulish medical experiments. Dachau, like all the Nazi concentration camps, was a veritable hell on earth. Yet even amidst such suffering and evil the light of God’s grace penetrated the dark. The priests secretly administered the sacraments, especially penance and anointing of the sick, and amazingly were allowed to have a makeshift chapel in the camp where the Eucharist was celebrated under the strict surveillance of the camp guards. Because there were bishops imprisoned at Dachau, some of the priest prisoners even organized a secret ordination of a deacon to the priesthood.


Heinrich Himmler on an inspection tour of Dachau in 1936
(three years after it opened)

One priest prisoner at Dachau said of his stay at the camp: "Three years of experience that I would not have missed for anything in the world.” This statement seems shocking but it was shared by many of these chosen ones -- the priests of the camp. Enduring such evil, they bore much fruit. An amazing brotherhood among the priests was forged: they upheld the dignity of the priest and of man in the crucible of Dachau. This book is an important addition to literature on the Holocaust. It is a powerful account of priestly sacrifice and courage proclaiming the Gospel in an environment of unspeakable evil producing profound purification. The camp enkindled in those who survived a renewed lifelong desire to build God’s kingdom through word and sacrament.


A  final book is the recently published Heroism and Genius: How Catholic Priests Helped Build—And Can Help Rebuild—Western Civilization by William J. Slattery. To call this book a masterpiece is an understatement! I consider this the Catholic Book of the Year 2017. Praise for this amazing work abounds. Catholic historian and economist Thomas Woods has said, “Father Slattery’s book is the final blow to the Enlightenment’s version of Western history, in which the Church was nothing but an obstacle to progress. I heartily recommend it.” Cardinal Walter Brandmuller, President Emeritus of the Vatican Committee for Historical Sciences, says of Fr. Slattery’s book, “Heroism and Genius will open windows to unknown vistas of history—and in a delightful way. As one travels through the chapters there is a sensation of climbing a mountain and being exposed to ever vaster panoramas of thrilling landscapes.” And the Canadian Catholic novelist and artist Michael D. O’Brien says of Fr. Slattery’s work, “This extraordinary book is an essential read for anyone desiring to understand where we have come from and where we presently are, what we were saved from and what we are in grave danger of losing.”

Fr. William Slattery was ordained to the priesthood in 1990 by St. Pope John Paul II. He has given Ignatian retreats in both English and French throughout North America and is presently working on a book on priestly formation.

In the introduction to Heroism and Genius, Fr. Slattery explains the three-part structure of the book: “Part I ...sketches an overview of recent conclusions among historians regarding the Church’s role in the forging of Western civilization...it explains that Catholic priests were its constructors...and it lays out the milestones in the saga from 200 through 1300 A.D.  Part II, comprising chapters 2 through 5, describes the gradual shaping from 300 to 1000 A.D. of the embryo of medieval Christendom: the sociopolitical-cultural unity that was the heart of Western civilization... Part III, comprising chapters 6 through 10, shows the decisive role of priests in  building social, artistic, and economic institutions that mark Western civilization as both original and originating in the Catholic matrix.”

In Part II entitled “Laying the Foundations of a New Civilization", (circa A.D. 300-1000), the author begins by quoting  G.K. Chesterton’s classic defense of Catholicism, Orthodoxy: “The most absurd thing that could be said of the Church is the thing we have heard said of it. How can we say that the Church wishes to bring us back into the Dark Ages? The Church was the only thing that ever brought us out of them.” With the Fall of Rome in the early 5th century and the invasion of the many barbaric tribes from the north, the Western world did, indeed, enter what could be accurately described as the Dark Ages. Too often the phrase "the Dark Ages" is used to label everything medieval or pre-modern: it was a phrase made popular during the so called Enlightenment which ushered in secular modernity. The rationalist myth of that era considered those who lived before the 18th century as marked by abysmal ignorance, superstition, and irrational religious beliefs. But which age strayed farther from reality?  Basil Wiley in his literary history of the 18th century described the "Enlightenment" as a historical period that was "dark with excessive light." The shrinkage of wisdom and Spiritual Blindness that marked the 18th century might more accurately be called the Age of Endarkenment. The bloody 20th century replete with scientific Marxism, racial Darwinism and atheistic feminism has borne its fruit. Humanity is still recovering.

During the correctly described Dark Ages (two or three centuries) after the fall of Rome, it was the Catholic Church and her leaders who saved Western civilization. Fr. Slattery focuses on four great Catholic bishops who stand as giants of thought and action. These men helped lay the foundations of the new Christian order. We know them as the four "Great Fathers of the West": St. Ambrose (d 397), St. Augustine (d 430), St. Leo the Great (d 461), and St. Gregory the Great (d 604). As the author points out, in the vacuum of civil leadership after the Fall of Rome, it was the bishops who shouldered responsibility for society and helped establish and maintain social order. Slattery presents four brilliant portraits of these great early bishops.

Especially impressive is his portrait of St. Augustine of Hippo and his dramatic change upon ordination. Fr. Slattery says, “The priesthood forged Augustine because its mission of teaching, sanctifying, and governing in the Church vigorously thrust him away from any tendency to make culture an end in itself, remote from the urgencies of the moment, and from the overarching purpose of life. It perfected his ardent, turbulent power for love, transforming it into energy at the service of the people since the priesthood exists not for the fulfillment of the individual who receives it but for the benefit of those whom he shepherds.” Later in his long essay on Augustine, the author provides this beautiful summary of Augustine’s greatest work, The City of God: “Systematically, Augustine’s work unfolds the idea that Christianity is no mere ‘religion’, a purely private relationship between the individual and God hidden within the conscience, but rather a revolutionary force capable of transforming society in all its dimensions—the answer to all the great questions about the purpose of history, human nature, marriage, family, education, justice, and the relationship of the individual and the state to the Church. In the measures in which civilization is built according to the divine blueprint offered it by Catholicism, it will be a society eminently worth of man. But the efforts to build will occur in wartime, for history is essentially a great drama, an unending battlefield until the world’s last night, on which the visible and invisible forces of good and evil fight for the conquest of man’s soul. Each individual must decide on which side he will combat, which city he will construct: ‘Two cities have been formed by two loves: the earthly by the love of self, even to contempt for God; the heavenly by the love of God, even to the contempt of self.’ ”

In chapter 4 entitled “Creative Minorities: the Benedictine and Irish Monks,” Fr. Slattery opens the reader to the foundational contribution of the monks and monastic life. “Benedict and his monks can rightly be called ‘The Fathers of European Civilization,’ for during the Dark Ages, their monasteries became ‘the storehouses of the past and the birthplace of the future,’ fortresses in which civilization sheltered beneath the banner of a saint: all that was noblest in learning and in culture was preserved in them...The monastery, in order to be ‘a school for the the Lord’s service’, was a community, a micro state, self-sufficient and agrarian, with its chapel, refectory, dormitory, workshops, mill, garden, guesthouse, and library. Self-contained it might well be, but it was certainly not designed to create men with 'ingrown eyeballs.' The Benedictines, like their Celtic and Egyptian brothers, were supposed to be men who entered the monastery not only for their own salvation but for the salvation of their fellow men.”

The Irish monastery of Skellig Michael (founded 7th century)

Fr Slattery paints a vivid portrait of these republics of prayer, study, work, and protection. The great achievements we will find in the cities and nations of Europe, we find first in the monasteries. These fraternities of work, prayer, and study are the seeds of the universal male suffrage and male citizenship movements that will emerge centuries later within the nations of Europe. Unlike the Greeks and Romans, the monks gave status to prayer, study, and to manual labor. Unlike the hereditary rulers of Empires, the monks built their social structure on fraternities of equals who elected their abbots. Artisan craftsmanship and agricultural innovation would emerge from their free labor. This communal immersion in the tasks of local community for the greater glory of the God of the Universe will forever mark the Catholic genius.

Saint Benedict is rightly called the Father of Western Monasticism and a Founder of Europe. Saint Columbanus [543-615], Saint Columba [521-597], and the Celtic monks played a major role as well through their monastic schools, their great skill in agriculture, and their ability to turn their monasteries into fortresses of justice by promoting law and protecting the poor from unscrupulous overlords.

A great advantage of historical works over many theological and philosophical tomes is the vivid appearance of personalities in historical contexts who make the Word become flesh. Fr. Slattery paints such priestly portraits: Alcuin, Charlemagne’s mentor and a major figure in promoting Catholic education and culture for the masses; St. Bernard of Clarivaux, a Cistercian monk of enormous influence both in the Church and civil society, called the "Conscience of the 12th Century"; and Pope St. Gregory VII in the 11th century, famous for his rigorous reform of abuses in the Church especially lay investiture, and for his excommunication of Emperor Henry IV of Germany.

A pleasant institutional surprise is his narrative of the genesis of free market economics first in the medieval monasteries and later in the Scholastic thinkers of what is called the School of Salamanca. Cultures forge certain kinds of personalities and personalities express those cultures. In-depth descriptions of the Ancient Rite of the Mass, the Gothic cathedrals, Gregorian chant, chivalry and knighthood, and the Templars set the cultural context that forged the great priests and bishops of these different eras.

In the conclusion of this magnificent history, the author explains why the Catholic Church will forever be the leaven for civilization: “One thing we do know for certain: the divinely constituted Church of Jesus Christ carries within her genes an eternal wisdom and energy that is capable of perennial rejuvenation. Neither persecution, nor inept or corrupt leadership, nor the catastrophes of history will ever succeed in devitalizing her. ’Christianity, remarked Chesterton,’ has had a series of revolutions and in each one of them Christianity has died. Christianity has died many times and risen again; for it had a God who knew the way out of the grave.’ Her vitality, so manifest in the passage from the catacombs to cathedrals in the first millennium, is fully capable of yet another herculean struggle to bring into existence another Christian civilization...The new Christian civilization may begin anywhere. Even, perhaps, once again in the West, in the Americas and Europe. The deeply Catholic culture that will inspirit this new civilization may rise elsewhere: the Church is larger and greater than the West. Her reality and her destiny are not bounded by the West’s frontiers: for she is Catholic, universal, and her future may flourish signally among the vigorous Catholics of Africa or among the Chinese, Korean, Vietnamese and other Asian peoples who, in increasing numbers, are intrigued by Christianity.”

The priests of a single diocese under a courageous bishop or a reformed religious house under a holy superior or a small Catholic nation under an eloquent statesman could spark the renewal. A single monastery or one truly reformed diocesan presbyterate can become "the creative minorities who will raise the phoenix of Christian social ideals from the ashes."

Heroism and Genius is a work of brilliance and beauty, a work of consummate scholarship written with exceptional intelligence, passion, and love for Christ and His Church. It is the kind of book one would like to put in the hands of every priest to reaffirm him in his priestly vocation. It is this reviewer’s hope and prayer that these books will be a source of inspiration for priests, young and old, and young men who may be discerning a vocation to the priesthood.

The Catholic priesthood today is in crisis. So is our country and so is humanity. It is a crisis that can be overcome by fidelity to Christ, the Eternal Priest, and by a spiritual reform of the brotherhood of fathers which Christ constituted. The great love of Mary for her Son that brought forth His Body is now present in another form of love which has been given the authority to effect the sacramental incarnation. "As my Father has loved Me, so I love you" and "so you should love one another" said Christ in instituting the sacral apostolic fraternity.

It was unwavering faith in Christ and fidelity to His Mystical Body that built Christian civilization. The same faith and zeal will rebuild the City of God. God has called all men into existence. He has called some men from all eternity to be ontologically conformed to Christ in a public love rooted uniquely in the love of the Father for His Beloved Son. These elected men can cast out demons and pray the Holy Mass. They forgive sins and proclaim that Christ has risen from the dead. They fish for men and draw us to eternal life with the Father through His Son. When priests answer their call, the nations will be baptized. They are the template of ordered brotherly love under the Father. Saint John Chrysostom, in his Patristic classic, 'On the Priesthood,' captured the splendor of the joyful priest: "The soul of the priest ought to blaze like a light illuminating the world."

May God grant the Church in our time such men ready to set the world on fire with the light and love of Christ.


Monday, February 5, 2018

Map on Monday: BURMA

The Physical Ecology, Communal Loyalties, and Geopolitics of Burma

by Dr. David Pence and A. Joseph Lynch


Physical Ecology: Natural Resources and Physical Geography

The core of Burma is dominated by the Irrawaddy river valley. The river runs north-south and roughly bisects the nation. At 1,348 miles in length and with a drainage basin 156,100 square miles (out of the nation's total of 262,000 square miles), it is also one of the most important rivers of Asia and home to various states and peoples over the centuries. The British Empire saw the value of this river and made its control an important imperial pursuit. Today the river generates electricity by way of hydroelectric dams. It acts as an important means of transportation, both in terms of people and goods (e.g. petroleum, cotton, timber, and local commodities). It also provides the water necessary for Burma's important rice production. 

Protecting the Irrawaddy core has always been problematic for peoples inhabiting the river valley. To the north and west, highlands and mountains form borders with India, Bangladesh, and China. The Hengduan Mountains form a natural border with China in the north while the Arakan Mountains create a border with Bangladesh and India. This physical geography led Burma to have greater communications with its southeastern neighbors (modern day Thailand and Laos).

Eastern Burma is dominated by the Shan Hills, a sparsely populated region home to Burma's many mineral resources. These include jade, sapphires, rubies, lead, silver, and zinc. This area is also more amenable to travel and communication, making it - along with Burma's long border with Thailand - an easy point of entry for migrating peoples. Burma is also home to oil and natural gas, with roughly half of it's drilling onshore and half offshore. It has been exporting crude oil since 1853, and remains today a vital oil and natural gas exporter in Asia.


Communal Loyalties: Ethnicity, Language, and Religion

Myanmar is a South Asian country of 53 million. The largest ethnic group is the Bamar (70%). In 1989 the military government changed many English names (like Burma) to ethnic equivalents (Myanmar). 88% of the people are Theravada Buddhist. 6% of the country are Christian and 4% Muslim.      

“Linguists have identified 110 distinct ethnolinguistic groups, and the government recognizes 135 ethnic groups (referred to as races). The Burmese account for about 68 percent of the population. Other major ethnic groups include the Shan (about four million) , Karen (about three million), Arakanese or Rakhine (about two million), Chinese (over one million), Chin (over one million), Wa (about one million), Mon (about one million), Indians and Bengalis (about one million)."

The ethnic Burmans—the people who ruled Pagan and dominate Myanmar today— didn't arrive until A.D. 9th century. Over a period of few centuries, they emigrated south from Tibet, passed through what is now the Yunnan Province of China and established settlements along the Irrawaddy River.
 The ancestors of modern Laotians, Thais, Burmese and Cambodians originated from southern China. The Burmans appear to have migrated south from Tibet to Yunnan in China, along with several other linguistic and cultural groups, more than 3,000 years ago. Anthropologists see them  as southern Mongoloids.

Burmese is the official and most widely spoken language in Myanmar. Spoken by about 70 percent of the population, it is Tibeto-Burmese language, a subfamily of the Sino-Tibetan family of languages language, which also includes Kachin, Chin and several tribal languages spoken in the Myanmar-China border region. The mother tongue of the Bamar, it is linguistically related to Tibetan and to the Chinese languages.  Burmese is a tonal language—like Thai, Chinese and Vietnamese—with five tones (meaning that words or syllables with similar sound have a different meaning depending on the high, low, rising, falling or level tone or pitch of the sound).

After 1914, the Buddhist element became much more nationalistic, and highly resistant to Christianity. Most Christians are from minority ethnic groups. There was hostility toward the Christian Karens as well as Indian immigrants.  The Protestant population reached 192,000 in 1926, with the Baptists in the forefront. When the Japanese seized Burma in 1942, the British and American missionaries fled, but they returned in 1945. Independence from Britain came in 1947, and for years there was simmering tension and sometimes military action by the government against the Karens. This strengthened the Christian religiosity of the Karens minority, and deepened the hostility of the majority Buddhist population toward Christianity. In 1966 all foreign missionaries were expelled by the Burmese government,  The growth in conversions of minorities to Christianity was related to the rise of Buddhist nationalism, closely tied to ethnic Barma identity. The Chin minority group grew from 35% Christian in 1966 to 90% in 2010; the Kachin minority group likewise grew from 40% in 1966 to 90~95% in 2010.  Most Muslims live in the northwest provinces. The largest ethnic group of Muslims are the Rohingya who are not recognized as a native ethnicity eligible for citizenship (see below).


Geopolitics: Political Geography and Foreign Policy

British colonization after the Anglo-Burmese wars (1824-85) brought many Hindus and Muslims from present day India and Bangladesh into Burma. (Best map explanations here). The Burmese nationalist movement in the 1920's portrayed the immigrants from the subcontinent as part of  British colonization. The newcomers dominated industries and the colonial government. They were never perceived as seeking a common Burmese citizenship with the locals. The Burmese nationalist movement  rooted their nationalism in indigenous precolonial ethnic identities and the Buddhist religion. In 1942, Japanese forces invaded Burma and during the British retreat communal violence erupted. Attacks were made against those groups that had benefited from British colonial rule. Burman nationalists attacked Karen and Indian communities, while in Arakan Rakhine, Rohingya villagers attacked one another causing a displacement of Buddhist villagers to the south and Muslims to the north. Many Burmese nationalists welcomed the Japanese as liberators of the nation from British Imperialism. Most prominent of these was Aung San (1915-1947), the Father of the Nation and organizer of the Burmese Independence Army(1941). The region remained under Japanese control until a British offensive drove out the Japanese in 1945. Prior to the Japanese invasion, the British, seeking to bolster support for their forces, had promised the Muslims of northern Arakan a Muslim National Area.

After Burma became independent in January 1948, tensions between the government and the Rohingya grew. Immediately following independence, a group of Arakanese Muslims went on the political offensive, pushing for the integration of Maungdaw and Buthidaung into what was then known as East Pakistan. That proposal was rejected by the Constituent Assembly in Rangoon. The government treated the Rohingya as illegal immigrants.

The immigration authorities imposed limitations of movement upon Muslims from the regions of Maungdaw, Buthidaung, and Rathedaung to Akyab [Sittwe]. Some 13,000 Rohinga still living in refugee camps in India and Pakistan whence they had fled during the war, were unable to return. Those who did manage to return were considered illegal Pakistani immigrants.

Beginning in 1950, segments of the Rohingya community resorted to armed action, led by armed groups called Mujahids. The Pakistani government in 1950 sent a warning to its Burmese counterparts about the treatment of Muslims in Arakan. However, Burma's Prime Minister, U Nu,  negotiated an understanding according to which Pakistan would no longer provide weapons to the Mujahids. In 1954, authorities in Pakistan finally arrested Cassim, the leader of the Mujahids. In November 1954, the Burmese army stepped up counterinsurgency operations in Arakan and quieted the rebellion.  Shortly after General Ne Win and his Burma Socialist Programme Party (BSPP) seized power in 1962, the government began to dissolve Rohingya social and political organizations. In 1977, Burmese immigration and military authorities conducted what they called Operation Nagamin (Dragon King), a national effort to register citizens and screen out foreigners prior to a national census. By May 1978, more than 200,000 Rohingya had fled to Bangladesh ( In 1971, the Bengalis of East Pakistan fought a war of liberation establishing Bangladeshi as a sovereign nation. 162 million strong, 98% Muslim, it is the world's 8th largest nation and 4th most populous Muslim country.)  The Burmese authorities claimed the Rohingya affinity for Bangladeshi was more proof that they were not really of Burma. Refugees reported that the Burmese army had forcibly evicted them and alleged widespread army brutality, rape and murder. (SECTIONS OF PRECEDING 3 PARAGRAPHS PATCHED FROM RELIABLE PUBLIC SOURCES)

A 1982 law defining Burmese citizenship deliberately excluded the Rohingya people (defining them as a Muslim Bangladesh ethnic group that settled in Burma under the cover of colonization) as a native ethnic group constituting the Burmese nation. They excluded as natives anyone who could not show ancestry before 1823. The 1 million members of the Northwest state of Rahkine (bordering Bangladesh) are thus considered stateless and were advised to return to their previous homeland. This narrative of all Rohingya only coming with the British is highly disputed by Muslims who claim much longer ancestory in Arakan where they were also persecuted in the 17th century.  In the last two years close to 10,000 Rahkine Muslims have been killed and 400,000 to 900,000 have fled-- mostly to  Muslim Bangladesh. It is ethnic cleansing by exile fed by brutal whole village exterminations to threaten those who might wish to stay. It is mindful of the wholesale ethnic/religous slaughter and mass migrations of the Indian partition in 1947 (15 million displaced; 1.5 million dead). 

The replacement of Burma's military government (ruled 1962-2011) by the NLD party led by female democracy advocate Aung San Suu Kyi has actually increased the propensity of nationalist advocates to take to the streets and expel their Muslim neighbors. Like the Arab Spring, so called democracy movements often unleash deeper communal identities and hatreds which eventually shape the course of events. The American press has been fairly incoherent in explaining this story. The photo shots of Hillary Clinton toasting Aung Kyi attest to the poverty of the democracy plus female empowerment=progress narrative. In the 200 year struggle for Burmese nationhood, Aung San (1915-1947), the father of Aung Kyi and the Father of the Nation looms large. He was an organizer of the Burmese Independence Army(1941)  and sided with the Japanese initially in WWII as a fighting alternative to British colonialism. He was the founder of the Burmese Communist Party as well.  His assassination in 1947 left his daughter a symbolic figure of national identity. How that national identity will be formalized and who will lead the country is a work in progress. Here is one account that takes religion and history seriously in explaining the carnage and resettlement. 

Religion, nations, and men - we must learn to speak the real grammar of history to understand these events. Buddhists expel "old Muslim invaders" in Myanmar.

Saturday, February 3, 2018

Religion and Geopolitics Review: Saturday, February 3

by Dr. David Pence and A. Joseph Lynch

WEEKLY BRIEF
                                                                A Real Threat to the President.                                                       
        The Need for a Cultural Restoration to Open A New Front to Protect Him 
It is becoming clear that at the highest levels of the FBI, State Department, DOJ, and National Security agencies, the opposition to the presidency of Donald Trump bore such a sanction of national preservation and moral righteousness that standard rules and modes of behavior were abandoned.  The hysterical resistance of most of America's national media and university culture to the reality of a President Trump betrays a group psychosis which must be penetrated before truthful public discourse can emerge. This is not a Hillary Clinton conspiracy but the frenzy of a colony collapse.
San Francisco football players who played with Joe Montana as their quarterback said in the mounting tension and crowd clamor of close games, Montana's voice grew calmer in the huddle. The offensive unit had a beacon of clarity in the midst of chaos and usually resolved the contest favorably. So now it will be the calmest voices--a  Paul Ryan more than a Ted Cruz who will help explain what the Inspector General is eventually going to reveal.
We should all remember there are many interests who opposed Donald Trump and American nationalism. The feminists were united across party lines. Careerism is not a unifying conspiracy but a centrifugal force of individual advancement set against a culture of national purpose. Feminism is careerism organized as a middle class ideology masquerading as a morality play. It is Hillary Clinton and Megan Kelly.  They hate Mr. Trump viscerally and provide emotional intensity for multiple beta male actors who have their own agendas  in this "Slay the alpha male " drama.
The whole moral pretense and narrative of the resistance to Donald Trump as President must be refuted. That means racism, masculinity and Christianity must be reformulated in public life. This cultural initiative is not President Trump's duty. He is the hammer but we must provide a Christian anvil built on a stronger and more secure foundation than even his own considerable courage and profound love of country.  He has forged a space for other men who can make wider and deeper arguments. Christians and patriots must take advantage of this moment that only Trump could give us. American men in our churches, workplaces, cities, states, and culture networks must radically reformulate the categories we use in political speech. As men of God and fellow patriots, we must repeal the sexual revolution and all its hate and bitter fruits.
We must first aggressively reject the equation of racism and nationalism.  There is nothing racist about drastically reducing foreign immigration until we fully integrate as fellow citizens the people(mostly of color) who are already here. Build a wall. Amnesty for DACA and long term illegals. Reform our failed black male socialization prison system and bring those brothers back into our religious and work communities. Don't demand they go to college. Quit suppressing wages of manual laborers with endless foreign competition. Teach the trades again and target young males for training. The feminist globalization paradigm of the Clinton Democrats destroyed the political authority of the male working class. The Ivy league power couples  took the needs of non college educated males off the public agenda.  Free market Republicans cheered the "new Democrats".  The black men on the street were jailed and the black Democratic office seekers  embraced feminism as an issue and corruption as a way of life. The most Christian and masculine ethnic group in America became a reliable voting bloc for the white college women replacing working men in the Democratic Party. No one suffered more than black males from the de Christianization and white collar feminization of the Democratic Party.
Every cell needs a cell membrane to protect the integrity of its internal organization. The nation needs an exterior border to renew our internal common life. The nation is a territorial interracial community that binds men as brothers not black predators, white fruits and brown laborers. Build a wall, meet your neighbor.  The white college educated globalists with a few colored spokespersons and a lot of foreign refugees have had their run. The real "dying whites movement' is  Angela Merkel's Eurocrats and Elizabeth Warren painting herself as a leader of inner city Democrats.  The bureaucratic state and overly credentialed college women are on the way out.  Religious nations led by strong male leaders are reemerging. Christian America must find our proper place among the nations  after the 30 year disaster of the baby boomers globalizing  their atheistic sexual revolution under the banner of human rights.
This is a dangerous time for Americans who believe in presidential elections. We have seen presidents destroyed and discredited before by the University-Government-Media leftist elite. The Texan LBJ dare not run again; the landslide winner Richard Nixon resigned; the two time elected President George W Bush was a humiliated White House recluse spending his last months in office  with a barely hidden grin awaiting release from his duties. We also remember the nationalist President who loved the duties of his office. He was a Catholic warrior Democrat who won over the media but was assassinated by the violent left. The weak men are chased out; the strong men must be shot. This is a dangerous time indeed.
 Those who wish the renewal of the American nation must open a cultural front of public prayer to our Sovereign Father and interracial brotherhood among men.  We must put the disruptive sexual genie back in the bottle and promote marriage between man and woman as the sanctuary of  interpersonal sexual intimacy. We must praise virginity and put the brown wrapper back on pornography.  Motherhood not abortion is our definition of female liberty and maturation. We must speak clearly, calmly, boldly, and  truthfully.  We must show piety for the name of God and reverence toward our flag. Before we outlaw we must stigmatize the anti-life abominations which have flourished in the Sexual Revolution. American nationalists must regain control of our government and rid ourselves not of Russian influence but Saudi Arabian actors who are the actual foreign enemy colluders who have fomented decades of foreign policy confusion. In his campaign, Donald Trump  said we have to figure out "where the hate is coming from" and "what the hell is going on." That is starting to happen. If we keep looking and telling the truth we will uncover multiple pathetic government males jockeying for favorable offices with a presumed feminist President. But once the careerists are peeled away, we will find much larger purposeful and dangerous actors corrupting our government. We will begin to see the role of foreign national lobbyists and agents who misdirected our foreign policy elite in the American war against Islamic jihadists.        


I. POPE FRANCIS AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH

THE POPE, CHINA, AND THEOPOLITICS: If one reads the Catholic American conservative press, the evil Pope Francis is selling out the true Christians in China for the red tyrant government in the same way he has betrayed dogmatically correct conservative prelates and Church teaching in his approach to Catholic families, marriage, divorce and the sacraments. Could there be something more going on in dealing with how China and the Catholic Church will relate in the next century? Is it even possible the pope has a much larger Catholic vision of the Church, the nations and the great Sino civilization reappearing as a principal actor on the world stage. Here are a few essays to consider on the Pope's diplomatic thinking. Much of this is based on a recent article by Fr Jose Luis Narvaja concerning Jose Bergoglio's political thought. An interview the Pope did with Asia News on the rise of China is quite instructive as well.

THE POPE'S INVESTIGATION OF CLERICAL ABUSE IN CHILE IS NOT OVER - IT TAKES A NEW START: From National Catholic Reporter, Dennis Coday, Jan 30,2018: "Pope Francis is sending Archbishop Charles Scicluna of Malta to Chile to take testimony about Bishop Juan de la Cruz Barros Madrid of Osorno, Chile, who is accused of covering up allegations of abuse by a Chilean priest who was found guilty of abuse."

THE CUT FLOWER OF MORALITY WITHOUT RELIGION: "The attempt made in recent decades by secularist thinkers to disengage the moral principles of western civilization from their scripturally based religious context, in the assurance that they could live a life of their own as 'humanistic' ethics, has resulted in our 'cut flower culture.' Cut flowers retain their original beauty and fragrance, but only so long as they retain the vitality that they have drawn from their now-severed roots; after that is exhausted, they wither and die. So with freedom, brotherhood, justice, and personal dignity — the values that form the moral foundation of our civilization. Without the life-giving power of the faith out of which they have sprung, they possess neither meaning nor vitality." Will Herberg, Jewish believer and writer (d. 1977).

BOB DYLAN'S CHRISTIAN MUSICA review about the haunting fire and brimstone music from that era in his life released now in a set Trouble No More.


II. GEOPOLITICS IN THE TRUMP ERA

IN YEMEN, THE UAE BREAKS FROM SAUDI ARABIA: A separatist group supported by UAE takes over Aden - the southern port city capital. The Saudi-backed Yemen President is now like the Saudi crown prince MbS. He is more and more isolated. 

HENRY KISSINGER - HIS NETWORK, HIS WORK: Essay about breakthrough to China and other Kissinger initiatives by his biographer Niall Ferguson - an excellent English historian.

BEN SHAPIRO - CONSERVATIVE, ORTHODOX JEW, ANTI-TRUMP - GOING VIRAL: A profile.

TOO MANY WARS, TOO MANY ENEMIES: Pat Buchanan is very good at guiding us around the globe and assessing our situation. The Hate Trump movement has grievously misdirected our national conversation about our place among the nations.

VIETNAM - CHINA'S ALLY, CHINA'S FOE: The different roads ahead in the South China Sea and the changing options of Vietnam in relationship to the US and China.


III. CULTURE OF LIFE, CULTURE OF PROTECTION

SALVIFIC NATIONALIST MASCULINITY: A Review of 12 Strong. The apostles were 12. Juries are 12. Football teams are 11. SFODA is 12 (Special forces operational unit). A Jewish minyan is ten men. A city cannot have its own synagogue unless it has enough men to make a minyan. Some prayers can only be said by a minyan. Some acts can only be done by a MALE PUBLIC. The Apostles and tribes of Israel were TWELVE. This is a pattern of the male operational unit - a small functional public that  represents a larger male group that forms the lattice of a community of men, women and children.

HOLLYWOOD OSCARS ROMANTICIZE A VERY DIFFERENT NARRATIVE OF A MALE COMING TO AGE: Call Me by Your Name review. There really is a culture war in America. One side with a lot to hide is brazenly a lot more bold in praising exploitation as a portrait of love.

"ME TOO" AND FEMINISM: An essay on the history of conflicted feminism about gender differences and sexual liberation.

BLACK MEN IN PRISON:    There is so much in this documentary 13th that draws the wrong conclusions, highlights the blatant exception and proposes incomplete analysis. HOWEVER there is a searing power here from the black woman director Ava DuVernay who also produced the gripping but flawed movie Selma. Anyone interested in renewing the American nation and male socialization cannot ignore where a huge group of young black males are living.